Saturday, April 25, 2009

Was Jesus really the son of Mary & Joseph?

Why should we assume Jesus was the son of Mary and Joseph?

If we discount the two Bethlehem stories, which are probably fictitious, there is very little biblical attestation to Jesus being part of the Mary & Joseph family.

The references are there, but they are very few.

At the crucifixion scene, Mary is identified as the mother of James, but not as the mother of Jesus, who is dying before her. Why shouldn't the text say this was Jesus' mother?

Some interpreters say this was a different Mary. However, it's a clear reference to the same Mary of Mt. 13:55/Mk. 6:3, which names the brothers James and Jose (Joseph) and are the only biblical texts (along with Acts 1:14) which name Mary as Jesus' mother (outside the two fictional Bethlehem stories of Matthew and Luke).

In the Gospel of John, the mother of Jesus is mentioned several times, but never named as "Mary". Why?

And the idea that Mary's son James was the brother of Jesus is mentioned only once (Gal. 1:19) outside the Mt. 13:55/Mk. 6:3 reference.

(The above Matthew and Mark texts are really the same basic source, one being essentially a quote of the other.)

So outside these few references, there is nothing identifying Jesus as the brother of James or son of Mary (if the fictional Bethlehem accounts are discounted).

The two Bethlehem stories are totally unreliable. They share nothing in common except that Jesus was born to Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem, and they ended up in Nazareth some time later.

Other than this, the two stories depart from each other entirely.

Matthew says nothing about the decree sent out from Caesar Augustus, which would have disrupted the lives of millions of people in the Roman Empire, and also nothing about the famous manger scene of Luke (the "nativity"). Rather, the 3 wise men find the child in a "house" rather than a stable near an inn.

And Luke totally omits any reference to the famous star over the town of Bethlehem and also any reference to the wicked king Herod or the long journey Mary and Joseph took down to Egypt before going up to Nazareth.

Each writer is totally oblivious to anything contained in the other's account.

The notion that Jesus was the son of Mary and Joseph and had a brother named James could very well be a later tradition which became popular some time after 40 A.D. as interest in the background of Jesus increased and the writers needed to fill in the details of his family roots.

The name "Jesus" was very common and could have been the name of a son of Mary and Joseph (perhaps the prisoner Jesus Barabbas) with whom the crucified one eventually became confused, while the connection to Mary is that she was one of the many women who followed Jesus, perhaps being the most attached to him of these several women who followed him to Jerusalem.

It doesn't make sense for Mary to be identified as the mother of James rather than as the mother of Jesus who is dying on the cross right in front of her, or for John's gospel to omit her name entirely if her name was known.